Is Smile 2 woke?
Smile 2 (2024)
Movie
Released: January 1, 2024
Wokeness Score
3/10
Light Social Awareness
Some light diversity or inclusion elements that feel natural and organic. Woke themes are subtle, non-intrusive, and fully integrated into the story without drawing attention to themselves.
Key Summary Points
- Organic diversity with female lead of color and minor gay character, no forced representation.
- Fame and addiction themes serve horror plot, not ideological lectures.
- No DEI agendas or identity politics; focuses on scares and story.
Wokeness Analysis
Smile 2 prioritizes supernatural horror and psychological terror over progressive ideology, delivering a sequel that expands the chilling curse concept into the high-stakes world of pop stardom without forcing political agendas. The lead, Naomi Scott as Skye Riley, a recovering addict preparing for a comeback tour, drives the narrative through her personal demons amplified by the smiling entity, focusing on universal themes like trauma, addiction, fame's dehumanizing pressure, and mental deterioration. While some left-leaning outlets interpret the film as an allegory for capitalism or neoliberal exploitation—such as Jacobin's claim of it portraying 'dehumanizing capitalism' where performers are valued only for productivity—these readings feel stretched and secondary to the gore-filled scares and plot propulsion. Diversity exists organically: Scott is a woman of color in the starring role, supported by a cast including Latino actor Miles Gutierrez-Riley as a gay assistant and others, but no characters lecture on identity, representation, or social justice. Conservative reviewers note minor elements like an effeminate male assistant but deem them non-intrusive, with no evidence of DEI-driven casting or shoehorned messaging alienating audiences. The film's commentary on celebrity culture—pressures to 'smile' through pain, controlling managers, obsessive fans—integrates naturally into the horror, enhancing tension without dominating entertainment. Critics across spectra praise Naomi Scott's raw performance and director Parker Finn's elevated production values, jump scares, and twists, confirming the story and escapism remain paramount. Absent are preachy monologues, virtue-signaling subplots, or marginalized group spotlights that halt the action for indoctrination, making any modern sensibilities mild and unobtrusive.
Plot
Smile 2 picks up six days after the original, with the curse passing from Joel to drug dealer Lewis, who infects pop star Skye Riley (Naomi Scott). Recovering from substance abuse and a car crash that killed her boyfriend Paul, Skye prepares for a massive comeback world tour amid mounting pressures from her manager mother Elizabeth (Rosemarie DeWitt), assistant Joshua (Miles Gutierrez-Riley), and fans. As rehearsals intensify, Skye experiences horrifying visions of smiling figures—hallucinations blending her guilt, trauma, and the entity's torment—eroding her sanity. She seeks help from therapist Dr. Morgan (Kyle Gallner), reconciles with estranged friend Gemma (Dylan Gelula), and confronts her past, but the curse demands a gruesome transfer. The film escalates with brutal kills, possessed dancers, and reality-blurring sequences culminating in a stadium finale where Skye's on-stage breakdown spreads the horror exponentially. Parker Finn's direction amplifies gore, sound design, and Naomi Scott's visceral performance, blending psychological dread with supernatural spectacle.